Brazil Federal Court Overturns CDA Gaming Injunction – Operations Halt Amid Legal Uncertainty
Brazil Federal Court Overturns CDA Gaming Injunction – Operations Halt Amid Legal Uncertainty
Key Takeaways
- The TRF-3 President revoked a temporary injunction that had authorized CDA Gaming to operate three brands in Brazil.
- Lower court decisions circumventing Provisional Measure 1.394/2026 were deemed a concrete risk to public order.
- Attorney General Paulo Gonet petitioned the Supreme Federal Court to suspend all ongoing lower court lawsuits regarding the measure.
- CDA Gaming had already launched Casa de Aposta and Betsul before the ruling forced a shutdown.
TRF-3 President overrides lower court decision on betting prohibition
The legal dispute over betting regulations in Brazil advanced on Friday when CDA Gaming lost its temporary authorization to operate. Luís Antônio Johonsom di Salvo, president of the Federal Regional Court of the 3rd Region (TRF-3), suspended an earlier injunction. This prior ruling had temporarily protected the operator from the enforcement of Provisional Measure 1.394/2026, which prohibits betting activities in the country.
The Attorney General’s Office (AGU) initiated the appeal against Judge Adriana Pileggi. She had initially ruled in favor of CDA Gaming, suspending the effects of the provisional measure for the company. Pileggi based her decision on the short timeframe given for license terminations.
She argued that sudden enforcement caused undue harm to authorized companies. Her ruling explicitly cited a disregard for constitutional principles of legal certainty, reasonableness, and proportionality.
Court prioritizes national public policy over temporary business relief
Johonsom di Salvo rejected the lower court’s reasoning by focusing on the broader implications for national governance. He characterized the continuation of betting operations under such injunctions as a concrete risk of serious harm to public order. Maintaining the temporary protection, according to the TRF-3 president, creates a scenario of normative instability.
He declared this instability incompatible with the management of a national public policy. The overarching legal questions regarding betting and the provisional measure are currently sub judice before the Supreme Federal Court. Johonsom di Salvo argued it is inappropriate for lower courts to anticipate the ultimate rulings of the highest court.
He justified his intervention by noting the merits of the case had not yet been submitted to the full court. He cited his authority under Article 4 of Law No. 3,437/92, affirming that the competence of his presidency prevails in this specific context.
CDA Gaming faces operational halt for three specific brands
The reversal of the injunction directly impacts three distinct brands managed by CDA Gaming. The operator had already launched Casa de Aposta and Betsul online following the initial favorable ruling from Judge Pileggi. These active operations were forced to cease once the TRF-3 president overturned the decision.
A third brand, Jogo da Sorte, was also included in the original legal protection. The TRF-3 president overturned the injunction before Jogo da Sorte could officially go live. The rapid succession of these rulings highlights the volatility operators face when relying on temporary lower court orders.
Previous rulings establish a pattern against temporary injunctions
The CDA Gaming case is not an isolated incident within the TRF-3 jurisdiction. Johonsom di Salvo explicitly referenced a previous, identical sequence of events involving the operator Stake. In that instance, Judge Pileggi had also granted Stake the right to temporarily resume its operations.
Johonsom di Salvo intervened and overturned that decision as well. The TRF-3 presidency is consistently blocking lower court attempts to bypass the provisional measure. This pattern reinforces the court’s stance that piecemeal authorizations disrupt the national regulatory framework.
Attorney General seeks comprehensive freeze on lower court actions
The Attorney General’s Office anticipates continued legal challenges from operators seeking to avoid the effects of Provisional Measure 1.394/2026. Attorney General Paulo Gonet has formally asked the Supreme Federal Court to intervene on a national scale. He requested the suspension of all proceedings across Brazil that debate the constitutionality of the measure.
The primary goal of this request is to prevent the proliferation of individual lawsuits and conflicting lower court decisions. Gonet wants all actions halted until the Supreme Federal Court issues a final, binding ruling on the matter.
The Supreme Federal Court held a public hearing on betting last week. Minister Luis Fux stated he requires more time to thoroughly analyze the complex issue. While Gonet seeks to block regional decisions, officials acknowledge new lawsuits will likely arise and cannot simply be shelved without Supreme Court action.
Our Assessment
The TRF-3 decision against CDA Gaming underscores a strict judicial approach to enforcing Provisional Measure 1.394/2026 pending Supreme Court review. Lower courts granting temporary relief are facing immediate reversals by higher regional authorities prioritizing national public order. The AGU’s push for a nationwide suspension of these lawsuits indicates a strategic effort to consolidate regulatory control. Until Minister Luis Fux and the Supreme Federal Court deliver a final verdict, operators relying on regional injunctions face immediate operational risks and rapid legal reversals.
need press exposure?
We deliver solutions to any topic in the iGaming niche.