Lord Foster Demands Gambling Scrutiny for Pokémon Cards
Lord Foster Demands Gambling Scrutiny for Pokémon Cards – UK Regulator Rejects Classification Under Current Laws
Key Takeaways
- Peers for Gambling Reform chair Lord Foster argues that the resale value of Pokémon cards qualifies them as “money’s worth” under the Gambling Act 2005.
- The UK Gambling Commission stated that the potential for secondary market trading does not legally classify the sale of these cards as gambling.
- A newly established Gambling Policy Commission is currently reviewing the existing legislation to determine if a new Act is necessary.
- Draft EU legislation, the Digital Fairness Act, categorizes collectible card packs as “variable reward systems” with speculative features similar to gambling.
High-Value Resale Market Prompts Calls for Legal Review
Lord Foster, chair of the Peers for Gambling Reform (PGR), has formally challenged the UK Gambling Commission over the legal status of Pokémon cards. In a letter dated 21 July 2026, Foster questioned why these trading cards are excluded from gambling legislation. He argued that the established secondary market gives the cards an objectively ascertainable financial value. This characteristic raises questions about whether the cards meet the definition of “money’s worth” outlined in the Gambling Act 2005.
Pokémon cards function primarily as part of the Pokémon Trading Card Game, where players use character abilities to win opponents’ cards. Demand and market prices have surged in recent years, driven in part by content creators and the success of the Pokémon GO game. The financial stakes involved were highlighted last month when a collector in Woking sold his Pokémon collection at auction for £1.56 million. Foster used this case as clear evidence that cash trading takes place, suggesting the cards readily exchange for cash through lawful commercial channels.
UK Gambling Commission Rejects Claims to Prevent Criminalizing Collectors
The UK Gambling Commission responded by firmly rejecting the idea that trading cards fall under current gambling laws. Acting chief executive Sarah Gardner replied on 11 August, stating that the possibility of future resale on a secondary market does not turn a purchase into gambling. Gardner explained that Parliament did not intend for the Gambling Act to cover trading cards or football stickers simply because buying them involves an element of chance.
The regulator remains focused on protecting vulnerable people from gambling-related harm but must operate within the strict definitions established by Parliament. Gardner warned that applying stringent gambling requirements to trading cards could have unintended consequences. Such a move might prevent young people from participating in a common hobby or potentially criminalize them for collecting cards. The Commission confirmed it is not currently undertaking any regulatory activity regarding the purchase or trading of collectible cards.
European Draft Legislation Targets Variable Reward Systems
Foster described Pokémon cards as part of a wider category of products that feature gambling-like mechanics. He has previously pushed for tighter scrutiny of similar systems in video games, such as digital loot boxes. The debate surrounding randomized purchases extends beyond the UK, with new regulatory frameworks taking shape across Europe. The recently drafted EU Digital Fairness Act proposes strict rules for paid “variable reward systems” across digital and physical platforms.
This draft legislation defines variable reward systems as virtual items offering random rewards or variable odds acquired through payment. The draft explicitly names loot boxes, wheels of fortune, and collectible card packs as examples of these systems. The legislative text explains that these products are prone to causing unwanted consumer spending. The draft also states they can be harmful because they share speculative features traditionally associated with gambling.
New Gambling Policy Commission Initiates Legislative Review
The definition of gambling has faced repeated challenges from lawmakers seeking to modernize the regulatory framework. Foster pointed to a 2020 House of Lords report on gambling, which he helped produce, that specifically recommended updating the legal definition of gambling. Fresh scrutiny of the existing laws began recently with the launch of the Gambling Policy Commission (GPC).
Established at the beginning of November, the GPC has initiated a comprehensive review of the gambling laws and legislation in the UK. This review places particular emphasis on evaluating the details of the Gambling Act 2005. The committee will examine whether amending the current framework or drafting an entirely new Act will serve as the necessary next step for UK gambling regulation.
Our Assessment
The disagreement between Lord Foster and the Gambling Commission highlights a growing regulatory debate over randomized purchases with secondary market value. The UK regulator maintains a strict interpretation of the Gambling Act 2005, emphasizing that Parliament did not intend to regulate collectible hobbies. Pressure for reform persists through the newly formed Gambling Policy Commission and changing legislative approaches in neighboring jurisdictions. The draft EU Digital Fairness Act indicates that international lawmakers are increasingly willing to classify collectible card packs as speculative systems requiring regulatory oversight.
need press exposure?
We deliver solutions to any topic in the iGaming niche.